Brenda and Sonny are in shock as Suzanne enters with a little boy. She calls him Lucian and he is Brenda's son. Sonny quickly gets friendly with the kid and sends him to the kitchen for a snack so he and Brenda can grill Suzanne. Suzanne explains that she had Brenda drugged and induced labor in Africa. She then placed Lucian with adoptive parents and told Brenda he died to protect him from Theo. Sonny remains skeptical and tells Suzanne he plans to have her story checked. Suzanne encourages Sonny to do so. She asks Brenda if she wants her son; if not, she would be more than happy to take him. Theo is dead and no longer a threat. Unfortunately Theo also had Lucian's adoptive parents killed. Brenda insists that Lucian is not going anywhere and immediately bonds with the little boy. Later she reads him a story as Sonny watches with apprehension in his eyes.

At the Drake house Lisa explains she came over to give Kristina a book about how to cope with the stress of college applications. Kristina is touched, but how did Lisa know she was here? Lisa lies, saying a waitress at Kelly's told her. They chat some more and Lisa moves to go, dropping one of her earrings on the way out.

Patrick and Robin are getting dessert at Kelly's when they bump into Johnny. Johnny gets in Patrick's face about Lisa; he believes that he's the one to blame for Lisa's craziness, not Robin. Patrick thinks Johnny is only interested in Lisa because she reminds him of his nutty sister Claudia. Johnny's face darkens as he warns Patrick to never say Claudia's name again. Patrick orders Johnny to stay away from Robin and Emma. Later as they arrive home Robin sees that Johnny's words bother Patrick. She assures Patrick that she doesn't believe that Patrick is the root of Lisa's craziness and heads upstairs to check on Emma. Patrick finds Lisa's earring and asks Kristina about it. Kristina realizes it's Lisa, but tells Patrick it is one of hers; it must've fallen out of her backpack. After Kristina leaves, Robin comes to get Patrick with a sexy smile on her face and leads him upstairs…

Lisa arrives at Johnny's place for a booty call, but they are interrupted by a phone call. Johnny heads upstairs to take it as Lisa lets herself out. We learn that it's Anthony on the phone as Johnny tells his dad that he may have some leverage on Sonny.

At Abby's apartment Abby explains she hasn't asked Michael if he killed Brandon because she figures that if he did it, he would have told her already. Michael proclaims that he did not, but thinks Jason did.

Meanwhile Dante accuses Jason of killing Brandon to protect Michael. Jason orders Dante to talk to Diane as Dante says either Michael or Jason killed Brandon. The hit was sloppy and if it was Jason, Jason was probably in such a hurry to do it before Michael did. If Jason did kill Brandon, Dante is part grateful to get that creep out of Michael's life, but that doesn't make murder okay. Still he feels he has no choice but to prove that Jason did kill Brandon. After Dante leaves Jason admits that this is setting a bad example for Michael. Just when he thought he had a breakthrough with Michael, this happens…

Dante meets with Abby at Kelly's who swears that Michael didn't kill Brandon. Dante believes her and realizes this means Jason probably did. Abby asks Dante to check for other potential suspects; Jason getting busted would crush Michael. She adds that Johnny intends to cooperate if that helps. Dante becomes suspicious; when did Abby talk to Johnny? Abby explains Johnny came to offer his help which makes Dante wonder what Johnny's angle is. Meanwhile Michael arrives to Jason's where he learns that Jason didn't kill Brandon. Surprised Jason admits he thought Michael did. So the big question is who killed Brandon and can Jason and Michael find the culprit before the murder gets pinned on one of them?