Claudia gets in a horrific car accident trying to avoid a reckless driver. Carly, who happens to be close by, pulls Claudia from the wreckage. At the hospital, Patrick and Kelly tell Claudia that both her and her unborn baby's lives are at risk.

Meanwhile, Johnny walks in to see Sonny and Olivia kissing. Johnny informs Sonny that tests confirm that Sonny is the father of Claudia's baby. Sonny doesn't believe Johnny but later learns he was telling the truth as he sees Claudia being rushed into the emergency room.

Jason helps Michael cover his tracks when he admits he thinks he caused a car accident. Kristina fears she could have caused Claudia's accident. Sam picks up on Kristina's unease when she returns home. Sam and Jason suspect that either Michael or Kristina could have caused Claudia's accident.

Maxie is tempted to accept Spinelli's marriage proposal after seeing the beautiful ring he got for her. Maxie asks Spinelli for more time to decide about his proposal.